David Solomon is on a bit of a hot seat—which is curious from a stock market perspective.

Since he became CEO of Goldman Sachs Group (ticker: GS) in October 2018, shares of GS have climbed 45% versus a12% decline for the Bluestar Top 10 Banks Index.  Goldman shares have outperformed the S&P 500 over the same period, as well. And the firm’s vaunted investment banking and trading franchises are still the envy of the industry. All of which would seem to be enough to keep his constituents satisfied—and yet, that isn’t quite the case.

Advertisement - Scroll to Continue

For one thing, Goldman doesn’t shine so brightly when looking at other measures. There’s that unsuccessful, multibillion-dollar foray into the consumer business. And the fact that net income dropped nearly 48% last year to $11.3 billion and fell 18% in the first quarter.  

That those numbers don’t compare favorably with Goldman’s ancient foe, Morgan Stanley (MS), which has made a hard turn into the more-stable asset management business over the past decade, puts an even finer point on things. Shares of MS have outpaced GS over the past decade.